Controversy - Let's avoid it!
















The word controversy is a very scaring word for me. Though I pretend that I am least bothered about a controversy, I generally keep away from such discussions which lead to controversy. A discussion, which may become a total fruitless one, can reveal a lot about you in a point when you, like most, will also try to establish your own point of view.

Now, let's take up any latest topic or news for our discussion, be it IPL, Dada's (Saurav Ganguly) performance, the Maoist movement, the new political steps of Ms. Mamata Banerjee, a new movie like Pathsala / Houseful, the man / woman who is your boss, the concern you work for, literally everything you can have in your mind. Start a discussion, face the controversy and you have made yourself clear to others. You are rigid, hypocrite, selfish, moron, and whatever else the other party think you are, at that moment. And the result will be a "mental separation" between friends / colleagues / partners. So, these ultimately fruitless discussion in controversial topics will lead to nothing but pain.

In my opinion, let's first be in a place where there is no "we" or "they". Let's talk about some thing that will not lead to any controversy. The belief and disbelief of people will not confront each other in such topics, where both are ready to discuss without taking in a particular side. Let's talk about the golden era of something or about some people all of us respect. Say, "Kabiguru" (Preceptor) Rabindranath Tagore or Late. Mr. Satyajit Ray. We all respect them not only for their works alone but also their lives as human beings. Let's avoid controversial topics like Maoist movement or political matters, rather, the performance of an actor like Rudranil Ghosh, where he acted as a chimpanzee, in a movie "Love Circus" may be discussed.

I can still recall an incidence of my childhood, rather adolescence when Diego Maradona's controversial goal with his hand became a hot topic to discuss. I had a discussion with the father of one of my friends and I was against this goal because for a player it is unethical to score a goal which he knew was a handball. My friend's father argued that winning matters, how do you win doesn't. My friend has won the battle of life, much more than that I have, please don't ask me how, but I have lost the respect for his father for ever.

Enough of my demented rants, at last, I would like to mention that, this is a particular fortnight when two of the Bengal's pride came on earth. On 7 th May, "Kabiguru" (Preceptor) Rabindranath Tagore, the Nobel laureate, who left no stone unturned in the field of arts (his scientific articles were as good though!) but one, cinema. On 2nd May, Late Mr. Satyajit Ray was born, the Oscar winner film director, who mainly wrote for children and worked on the celluloid to turn the last stone, left unturned.

11 comments:

Subhasis : The Unexplored Destination said...

in context to Your childhood story, Controversy is good as it helped u to recognize the real character of a person.its good... Y to avoid it? And Rabindranath's life is also of full of controversies.. u know, every life has so, this can't b avoidable 4 any reasons.Who keeps distance frm such Dangerous Controversies may be he is a peace-lover or wants to be good in front of all. But if it is something personal and if it really leads to WAR/FIGHT/SEPERATION... then it should be avoided.

me_amitava said...

controversy is something that lends a different perspective to any issue or person. it should be there otherwise life would become so very dull, but entertainment should not be at the cost of peace of someone else's life.

Shankha said...

@Subhasis: Good to know that you strongly believe that controversies should not be avoided rather faced boldly. But, I believe, only if you are ready to fight for your point and ready to handle a permanent separation from the person / group of persons you are having the fight, you should carry on discussing about controversial topics with them.

Shankha said...

@me_amitava: Yes, people often take these controversies, the arguments, too seriously and personally. That's why I tend to avoid them altogether.

Subhasis : The Unexplored Destination said...

@shankha ... I think Your point is very Conservative and defensive... it may force U to compromise with ur believes and sometimes "silence is the manifestation of support", so ppl may understand u wrongly also wen u avoid.

Shankha said...

@Subhasis: I believe, if a discussion has not been taken as a healthy one and oneself may take it personally, then once again, he / she will understand you "wrongly". But, still there is a chance to avoid the "misunderstanding" if you remain silent. Conservative people are defensive, and offense is always the best defense. He / She who offends you repeatedly in a discussion is actually conservative and defensive.

Thanks for the comment! Expecting more.

Subhasis : The Unexplored Destination said...

I should not continue any discussion keeping in mind that whether one will misunderstand me,whether there will b an impact on the relation in the long run, whether it will b a healthy one or not.We need to fight for wat we belive(logically)... the rest depends on the oponent.

Shankha said...

Hum, sounds like "Gita". Good attitude. But I really do care to loose my near and dear ones and therefore prefer not to discuss any controversial topics with them. Again, this is one's personal belief only. Feel free to face the fruits if you are ready to reap the "controversy" between yourselves. All the best!

Thanks for commenting! The topic seems to become a really favorite one for you.

Subhasis : The Unexplored Destination said...

Thanks to u also... this controversy may help me to continue controversy with some controversial topics with the oponents whoever he/she is... dear one or a distant one.

island of peace said...

i too share your view on controversies- i avoid them like plague.

they are usually good for nothing and only leave bitter taste in atleast one mouth.

i believe in discussing, and if the other person is not interested to discuss i leave the topic.

i think bitterness is not worth spreading.

Shankha said...

@island of peace: Thanks for commenting.

Yes, I avoid discussing controversial topics as they are fruitless and of course create bitterness between friends.

Post a Comment

Hi!
Will be glad to know your honest views. That is invaluable for me.

Thanks a lot for visiting my blog.

Regards,
Shankha